I did really enjoy the book. The relationships were messy (as life is~ so very realistic) and haunted by secrets. The dual timeline was interesting because there was only a separation (at max) of a decade. I don't think I've ever read anything where the timelines were so close together & even overlapped? I liked the protagonists in both timelines a lot and despite their problems, I found Georgie & Bay's relationship especially endearing.
It started a bit slow for me but once I got beyond the first few chapters, I was hooked and trying to figure out who the murderer was. It was a bit of a surprise, although once it was revealed there was a gigantic jewel left at the scene, I began to direct my suspicions toward one person....turned out I was wrong. I'd make a horrible detective! I thought originally it was Anne, because of the way the author made her out to be a miserable, disagreeable & basically difficult to like personality but there again, another twist. I want to hope that Georgie survived (probably a long shot) but that's left ambiguous.
Quick read and well written. A gothic-style mystery (with a tiny romance) ~ if you like that kind of literature, this book is a treat.