** spoiler alert ** This book could have been absolute garbage and I would have loved it ~ that's how happy I was to be back in the 'Outlander' orbit. Of course it wasn't absolute garbage, far from it. Diana Gabaldon is way too intelligent of a writer to ever publish anything in that category. What a nonsensical way to start a review.
Lord John Grey is one of my favorite periphery characters from the 'Outlander' books. As such, it was like seeing an old friend, the warmth I felt at renewing our acquaintance. My approach to reading his series has been deliberately paced, in slow methodical fashion, so as to draw out my obsession pleasure with this world for as long as possible. 'The Brotherhood of the Blade' mentioned Jamie Fraser as part of the storyline which, of course, was an instant, bonus, no-brainer, decision-maker to reading the book. Sadly, Jamie was actually a very small (tho pivotal) part but it was nonetheless satisfying to read dialog between two of my favorite men in literature.
Now, don't count, but how many times have I waxed on and on about what a gentleman LJG is? Probably so many, everyone is doing a perfunctory eye roll at this very minute.
Too bad! I'm not quite finished yet nor can I ever imagine a day when that would be so.
I could go on and on about it ad nauseum ~ it's so particularly striking in this day where simple civilities are noticeably lacking. He makes me sigh, he's so perfect. How is it fair one man is as blessed in good attributes as he ~ looks, athleticism, manners, intelligence, wealth, noble birth family, etc.?? He's missing nothing except the ability to love openly, the person of his choice. No small thing that. I'm sure he would trade any one of the previous for the opportunity to be granted that freedom. Reading about what happens to sodomites in the British Army is sobering, as there is still much progress to be made in the world on that front. Diana Gabaldon wrote such an honest portrayal of love, lust, betrayal & anguish in the relationship between LJG and Percy Wainwright, I felt I lived it right along with him. It was so typical of LJG to find the best case scenario in how it ended. Of course he would. At the end of this book, it did not appear Percy & Lord John were on bad terms. However; (me being ever the stickler for details) I distinctly remember, when they crossed paths again in 'An Echo in the Bone,' Lord John was not very thrilled to see him. Perhaps in one of the few books I have left to read, they have a distasteful encounter? or is it possible I've forgotten something? hmmmm.
The other big storyline was the mystery of who murdered John Grey's father, the Duke of Pardloe and the sleuth work to figure it out. I won't spoil that part, for once!
I really enjoyed 'The Brotherhood of the Blade' although my favorite in this series (of the ones I've read) remains 'The Scottish Prisoner.' Mostly because Jamie & LJG comport themselves as equals in that excursion. This book fills in more details on events we 'Outlander' fans have read about in the regular series. We get a lot of insight into the depths of Lord John's feelings for Jamie. I felt pangs of empathy for him all over again that it was destined to be unrequited. Indeed, I could would love to commiserate with him over a brandy. *sigh* If only. The explosive argument between LJG and Jamie regarding homosexuality was very revealing and written to perfection. I'd always wondered if Lord John knew about what happened to Jamie with Black Jack but here was the answer. I was happy to learn it and I think it explained to Lord John, without question, Jamie's reaction to his advance at Ardsmuir. Despite their considerable differences ~ religion, politics, sexuality, etc. ~ they are inexorably drawn to each other in friendship. We could all learn a lot from DG's fictional world.